The ‘That’s What You Heard!’ Fallacy: How Postmodernists & SJWs Try to Run Rings Around Rational People

It’s very important not to waste time debating postmodernists; because, like other morally corrupt and nihilistic ideological extremists, they don’t believe in rational argumentation; only rhetoric. Some of them even say so!

You can, however, ‘Know Thine Enemy,’ and choose to read up on their devious rhetorical strategies.
One classic example is the ‘Motte and Bailey,’ where people sally forth with a hysterically exaggerated proposition that has both a ridiculously extravagant surface meaning and a more restrained secondary meaning. So, whenever you challenge them on the apparent meaning, they shriek in terror and hide behind the fortress of their less contentious meaning.

But the Motte and Bailey Fallacy is not just something negative. It also shows up very clearly the lack of conviction people have.


We (sic) need to create a tolerant and inclusive society.
OK. Is it time to include rapists, paedophiles, pimps, jihadists and Neo-Nazis then.
… WTF, dude?! No! No, no, no, I don’t believe in moral absolutes.

Power is decentred. This means it isn’t held or possessed by anyone; it isn’t top-down, like slaves and masters.
OK. So how come slavery has come back to Libya.
Ah… Well of course, er, um, I didn’t mean it was completely decentered. Of course it is centered in some people, it is possessed or held by some, er, um, but not necessarily forever! And people don’t necessarily have complete control, even if they have some!

Why is this lack of conviction important?
Because it helps shows how weak their arguments are.
It’s a good idea to expose the stupid ideas of relativists. Just make damn sure you don’t futilely squander your time, energy, money, mental health or other precious material and spiritual resources debating with these folks more than you should.
If you see someone who is already part of the way out, or at least having some fleeting doubts, then fine.
Case by case basis. (Postmodernists could definitely learn something about that one!)
But as for true believers? Spare yourself!
Focus your energies on winning the middle ground, or even the three-quarters ground.
But don’t waste your time on people who aren’t worth debating with.

Psst… Don’t forget to click on the Facebook post above; and like the page!
Of course, Glossy News has a page too…

Image attribution:
By Michael Hanselmann – Quaoar10Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, Link

Author: Wallace Runnymede

I've been writing satire for many years, and I've been published on many sites! Follow me on Twitter, and have a look at my books on Amazon! I've also had some poetry published by Sad Press recently: look out for 'Centrifugue!' I am also a founding member of the #AutisticDarkWeb: check the hashtag out on Twitter! Money's tight, so please consider dropping me $1 a month on Patreon (see link below). All my Patreon subscribers get certain benefits, including exclusive content, way in advance of anyone else!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.