Uncritical Pro AND Anti Immigration Stances? Sentiment, not Reality

Uncritical Pro AND Anti Immigration Stances? Sentiment, not Reality

Just have a look at my comment below, for an article on the site of the publisher Verso Books:

http://www.versobooks.com/blogs/2679-the-hegemonic-powers-of-the-eu-have-gone-one-step-too-far-on-governing-borders-and-the-right-to-move

Immigration is nothing to do with the question of deserving or not deserving this or that. Immigration is an entitlement, a legal provision; to confuse entitlements with desert is to confound a legal category with a morally charged ethical notion.

I further add:

Both far right populists and the ‘Worthy Left’ elements of the left reduce the question of immigration to mere sentimentalism and moralism, rather than serious, reality-based critique and discussion.

Those who treat exclusion as a moral absolute are wrong. They are detached from reality.

Those who treat inclusion as a moral absolute are wrong. They are detached from reality.

The shameless depoliticizing of immigration, under the guise of political discussion, is troubling.

To make this complicated and sensitive issue a rhetorical and emotive football is nonsensical and thoroughly self-serving. Immigration cannot be taken seriously as a political issue when it is reduced to the primitive, raw, pre-reflexive sentiment of bleeding-heart leftists OR bleeding-fist rightists.

As Zizek has so often said on a variety of issues, drily hat-tipping Stalin:

Which one is worse? They are both worse!

For Zizek, this means they are both founded on the same error.

 

Share

This post was written by

- who has written 352 posts on GlossyNews.com.

Currently co-editing Glossy News (under the webmaster, Brian K. White). Contact me to pitch or submit your satire! wallacerunnymede@gmail.com w_runnymede (Twitter) See my Facebook page as well: https://www.facebook.com/Wallace-Runnymede-125963814655515/ And my book serials: http://glossynews.com/author/wallacebooks/ You can by my ebooks from many stores, including Amazon. https://www.facebook.com/Wallace-Runnymede-125963814655515/

.

2 Responses to “Uncritical Pro AND Anti Immigration Stances? Sentiment, not Reality”

  1. President Trump says:

    Once I’m President I’m having this site deported.

  2. Deported? Ooo, shit! Sounds exotic. Can I take these hot-ass interns with me? :D:D:D

Trackbacks/Pingbacks


Leave a Reply


We are also looking for a satire editor
and a Clever Photoshop Guru...
Glossy News Exclusive Exposés


-- (SEE ALL GlossyNews.com Videos) --



Glossy News Fake Commercials!





Glossy News Podcast


(Listen on iTunes or Libsyn)


More Great Satire:

Check out links to even more of our friends...
Want to see Your Link Here?



Our Top Authors (last 30-days)

DHgate.com



All of Our Categories:

Top Stories - Top Stories; Politics - Top Stories; Serious Commentary - Top Stories; World News - Top Stories; Biz News - Top Stories; War Zone | Horoscopes
Entertainment - Entertainment; Celebrity Gossip - Entertainment; Television - Entertainment; Music - Entertainment; Internet Tubes - Entertainment; Books, Newspapers & Misc - Entertainment; Movies
Society - Society; Health - Society; Crime - Society; Travel - Society; Crooked Cops - Society; Education - Society; Strange People - Society; Religionism - Society; Human Interest - Society; Kidz Zone
Science and Technology - Science and Technology; Science - Science and Technology; Technology - Science and Technology; Gadgets & Gizmos - Science and Technology; Environment
Sports - Sports; Scandals - Sports; Athletes - Sports; Events | All the Rest - News in Your Briefs - Making Headlines - Opinion/Editorial